now systray implementation has got XEMBED support, so please test with latest
GIT revision or 0.9.20 when released

nope, like I said my bug report is about :

-minimizing from tray and then restoring window will move it to the left and up 
a litle every time

-minimizing by clicking minimize button on apps that support minimizing to tray 
will NOT minimize those apps _only to tray_ like they want, but also to "Window 
List", clicking app button in "Window List" will restore empty window, clicking 
tray icon will restore CROPPED horizontally window

I knew beforehand about tray icon being in the middle of moving from own window 
to tray notification area. BTW looks like XEMBED implementation doesnt support 
transparency in tray icons.


So to replicate this bug download
http://www.metal-machine.de/readerror/NetMeter_v0999beta2.exe
http://download.utorrent.com/1.6/utorrent.exe

in Netmeter every minimize and restore will move window to the left a little
in utorrent go to 'options/general/system tray' and turn everything on, now 
play with minimizing from tray and Window List, the window will crop or display 
only border :/

I confirm

"minimizing by clicking minimize button on apps that support minimizing to tray 
will NOT minimize those apps _only to tray_ like they want, but also to "Window 
List""

uTorrent mimizes to Window List, when trying to open it again by clicking on the
correspondig Window List Item, it doesn't restore correctly.

Created attachment 3568 [details]
Screenshot

Worth a thousand words...

Comment on attachment 3568 [details]
Screenshot

Sorry, wrong bug#

Same here with Google Talk and wine 0.9.20.
But minimizing to taskbar is the normal way in GT, also on windows though there
is a systray-icon(both in windows and wine). For only having it in systray icon
you have to use the "x"/close-button(though it doesn't work in wine either).
But after minimizing, it doesn't bump up again correctly, it is only showing
something wird in a box. That may be the same.

bump. 0.9.22 same
minimizing to tray when "close to tray" is checked in uTorrent works, 
minimizing with minimize button when "minimize to tray" is checked doesnt.
I suspect the window manager sees the minimize click and does its thing - 
minimizes anyway. Ill try it with something other than metacity and report back.

*** Bug 6074 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

Works for me on the latest git and with µtorrent 1.6. I'm using KDE 3.5.5

Distr: Kubuntu Edgy, with KDE 3.5.5 and QT 3.3.6, wine 0.9.29 wine ubuntu
repository.

If utorrent is minimized from inside application and then maximized from taskbar
back to full size, application window is 100% transparent and only borders are
shown.

This is huge problem because utorrent is the best torrent client atm in the
market :|

At least Minimize & Naximize by clicking utorrent systray icon works :)

My last comment about this bug:
"

Sry that problem dissappeared when I unselected setting "minimize to tray"  from
utorrent settings woohoo.

why are you sorry? this bug is EXACTLY about "minimizing to tray" :)

rasz: Oh I see :) Then its still bug... :p

*** Bug 7378 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

"minimizing from tray and then restoring window will move it to the left and up 
a litle every time"

With .9.31 it moves up like before, but left move is only 1 pixel, so something 
has changed :)

wine taskmgr has same problem, minimizing it = empty window and Window List item

Still present in 0.9.46 at least (haven't tested later).

The comments in bug 7378 are worth reading.

Nominating for 1.0, as some popular apps (uTorrent) 
and even a builtin app (Task Manager) seem to be broken by this bug.

(In reply to comment #17)
> Still present in 0.9.46 at least (haven't tested later).
> 
> The comments in bug 7378 are worth reading.
> 
> Nominating for 1.0, as some popular apps (uTorrent) 
> and even a builtin app (Task Manager) seem to be broken by this bug.
> 

Still present in wine 0.9.53. Doesn't move up and to the left for me, now is just moving up...

and doesnt move at all in wine 0.9.51

This promlem with uTorrent is irritating. with FC8 I don't use use the minimize button of the main window at all. instead I click uTorrent panel icon (shown close to clock on bottom right side of the screen after you start utorrent).This will solve the problem from user point of view... But it is still a fault in the way wine works.

*** Bug 3776 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

Ok, I debugged this with taskmgr.exe and uTorrent. When I send SW_MINIMIZE, everything works fine, but from winex11.drv it doesn't. When a minimize event is received we do:

data->lock_changes++;
ShowWindow( hwnd, SW_MINIMIZE );
data->lock_changes--;

The lock prevents SW_HIDE (which is done in response to the SW_MINIMIZE) to work. Removing the lock works, but is not the right solution. Alexandre Julliard said on IRC he would have a look at it. 

Is it only me, or is this bug fixed in the current git? My problem with minimizing my application which minizes to tray and restoring it again works now...

Markus

It should work better now, please retest.

(In reply to comment #24)
> It should work better now, please retest.
> 

Just tested in Kubuntu Hardy (kde 4.0.3)/wine-git, and there taskmgr will not hide when minimized, but goes to the system tray. I'll test feisty gnome tomorrow.

Works fine here with Ubuntu 7.04/Metacity 2.18.2

(In reply to comment #26)
> Works fine here with Ubuntu 7.04/Metacity 2.18.2
> 

Yeah, appears to be a KDE issue.

Testing in Ubuntu Hardy, eMule does not minimize to the system tray, and worse still utorrent is no longer even visible for me. I can't even see the tray icon.

This is actually a regression now for me on Gnome 2.22 in Ubuntu Hardy - in 0.9.58 utorrent shows its system tray icon when I start it, but in 0.9.59 it does not (although I occasionally see strange behavior like an existing system tray icon duplicated - neither one of them controls utorrent).

getting the same as Scott,  tray icon does not show utorrent icon, does not activate on any mouse click and does not open close the app , but the app still works. 
ubuntu 8.04 beta , wine 0.9.59, utorrent 1.77

april 10, 2007, 21:15 est , ubuntu 8.04 beta 5, gnome 2.22, wine 0.9.59-ubuntu4, utorrent-1.7.7. 

just got a partial upgrade and the problem reported by Scott Ritchie, that kind of confirmed, about the tray icon going buggy, (duplicating another tray icon, no menu , no togggling utorrent open/close). seems to have vanished, 

thanks to whom ever fixed it :-) 

Yeah I included the patch that fixes the regression in the 0.9.59 package included with Ubuntu Hardy.  eMule's tray minimize still doesn't work, however.

Marking fixed, this works for most apps now.

eMule's problem is that it only triggers on WM_SYSCOMMAND, which we don't send. It can be worked around by disabling window manager decorations and using the Wine controls instead.

The remaining problem with eMule is now under bug 13217.

Closing bugs fixed in 1.0-rc2.